Mike's Cigars

Mike's Cigars has become one of the most trusted names for premium cigars in Bay Harbor Islands, Florida, and the reputation stretches well past the local crowd. This is a serious cigar shop with a deep, well-curated selection, and the word around town is that they carry lines to suit just about any palate. On the shelves you'll find Padron, Oliva, Cohiba, Macanudo, My Father, AJ Fernandez, Camacho, Avo, Alec Bradley, CAO, Gurkha, Hoyo de Monterrey, Acid, Aging Room, Bauza, Room 101, New World, Vertigo, the 898 Collection, the Conor McGregor line, and Old Fashioned, among others. They also stock the Volition America line by Gurkha, which folks who support Folds of Honor make a point of seeking out here.

Beyond the cigars, they carry the accessories to go with them, and they know their way around a humidor question too. What people really rave about is the service, and a few names come up again and again. Ask anyone who orders from here and you'll hear about Dennis and his team pulling through for cigar parties, or Sol going the extra mile when a shipment ran into trouble in transit. We've heard from a newcomer to cigars who leaned on the staff for recommendations and got wowed every time, and from longtime buyers who've placed dozens of orders and won't shop anywhere else.

When a carrier lost or damaged a package, the crew here jumped in to make it right, often sending a replacement before the customer even asked. Regulars keep coming back for the careful packing too, with cigars showing up fresh and properly humidified, boveda packs included, even after a long trip. Locals are largely thrilled with the quality and value, though we'll be fair: one shopper had a frustrating go with a cancellation and a late-cancellation fee, so it's worth being clear on the order before you confirm. That aside, the overwhelming sentiment in Bay Harbor Islands is loyalty.

As one regular put it, they've never been disappointed. If you're looking for a cigar shop that takes real care with what they sell and how they treat people, Mike's Cigars earns its following.