Cigar House

If you know cigars around Lawrenceville, you know Cigar House. Ask anyone who takes the hobby seriously and Sal's name comes up fast. He owns the place, and he's the kind of guy who remembers you years after your first visit. Louis (a couple of folks spelled it Louise) rounds out the team, and together they've built a reputation as one of the highest-rated cigar shops in the area, with people happily driving thirty to forty-five minutes to get here.

The selection is what keeps regulars talking. This is a big shop with new humidors and a lineup that runs from bottom to top tier, so there's something for a first-timer and something for the collector chasing rare sticks. Brands people mention picking up here include Arturo Fuente, Davidoff, Rocky Patel, and plenty more. As one regular put it, chances are if you can name it, Sal stocks it. If you're new to all this, don't worry about feeling out of your depth. The team is known for spotting a beginner right away and walking them through the different styles until they land on something they'll enjoy.

Word around Lawrenceville is that the service is the real draw. People talk about being greeted at the door, given a quick tour, and made to feel at home. Sal has a knack for pulling together a package for an event, humidor and all, and the prices strike most folks as fair. The shop itself is meticulously kept, with clear rules so the cigars and the space stay in top shape.

A quick honest note: not everyone walks away thrilled, and one person felt a sampler was priced high and was frustrated by the no-returns policy on a sealed pack. That's the exception here. For most who walk through the door, this is simply the best cigar spot around, and they come back week after week.