Cigar Shop of Safa Express BP

The surprise here is the setting. This is a real, working humidor tucked inside a gas station, and locals in Lawrenceville will tell you not to let that fool you. People who know their cigars have walked in expecting the worst and walked out impressed. As one regular put it, this is far from what you might imagine from a gas station cigar, it's a legit humidor stocked with grade A smokes.

The humidor itself gets a lot of praise around town for how clean and well kept it is, and the selection runs deep with premium and top-tier cigars. Ask anyone who shops here and they'll point you to names like Romeo & Juliet among the variety on the shelves. The word around Lawrenceville is that these are the freshest cigars in town, and folks make a habit of stopping in to grab something for themselves or as a gift on the way to see family.

The person behind the counter is a big part of why people keep coming back. We hear the service is friendly and genuinely helpful, quick to make a recommendation and just as willing to track down a specific cigar you're after. The team stays eager to bring in new stuff, so there's usually something fresh to try. Prices land on the fair and reasonable side, which regulars appreciate.

There's no lounge here, so this is a spot for picking up and heading out. But the parking is ample and well-lit, and the shop stays open late, which makes it easy to swing by after hours for a good cigar at a good price. Cigar Shop of Safa Express BP has earned a reputation as one of the best-regarded cigar spots in the Lawrenceville area, and it's easy to see why people keep making the trip.