Mayfield Smoke Shop

If you find yourself in Little Italy, Mayfield Smoke Shop is the kind of cigar spot locals steer visitors toward. The word around Cleveland is that this little shop punches well above its size, with a wide selection of quality cigars kept perfectly humidified. Ask anyone who shops here and they'll tell you the staff actually know their sticks. One regular had a Bolivar recommended to them and walked out with a new favorite, calling it smooth with just enough bold flavor.

That kind of guidance is what keeps people coming back. Beyond cigars, they stock cigarettes and smoking accessories, and they've been known to carry tobacco that's tough to track down anywhere else in town, including Danish Export. Prices sit a touch above the cheapest options around, but people who shop here swear the quality is worth the little extra. Nicole owns the place, and her hospitality has become part of the shop's reputation.

We've heard about her welcoming travelers passing through on business, sharing the history of the shop, and even treating strangers to local cannoli and pizza to give them a taste of the neighborhood. Michelle gets plenty of love too, and folks who stop in usually leave saying the people are the best part. One visitor called it a refreshing experience and meant it. It's a solid four-plus star kind of place, well thought of by those who know it.

A few people have grumbled about the odd sharp exchange over parking or pricing, but that runs against the grain of what most folks find here: a friendly, knowledgeable cigar shop that fits right into the character of Little Italy. If you're picking up a familiar favorite or looking to try something new, this tobacco shop in Cleveland is worth the stop.