Culebra Cigars Company LLC

Culebra Cigars Company LLC has quietly become one of the best-regarded spots in Columbus for anyone serious about a good cigar. Tucked in the back of a wine store, it's a small shop, but people who shop here will tell you the size is deceiving. The selection is deep, the cigars are well cared for, and the atmosphere is the kind that makes you want to stick around. Ask anyone who has walked in and the first thing they mention is the people.

Gordon and the rest of the team have a reputation for treating everybody well, whether you already know exactly what you want or you're standing there with no idea what you're looking at. One newcomer put it plainly: he knew nothing about cigars, and the gentleman inside walked him through the options, explained the differences, and set him up to make a better pick next time. That kind of patience is why folks come back. We've even heard of Gordon opening up after hours for someone who showed up hoping to grab a couple of cigars, which tells you something about how this place operates.

The vibe here is part of the draw. There are good outdoor areas, and regulars from nearby Jimmy V's have made a habit of grabbing a cigar from Culebra and settling in on the patio after work. The owner is often around, friendly and genuinely knowledgeable, happy to talk shop with anyone who's interested. The word around Columbus is that once you've bought a nice cigar here, you don't bother looking anywhere else.

Fair value, a well-kept selection, and staff who actually want to help. For a cigar shop in Columbus, it's hard to do better than this little spot.