Cigar Merchant

If you know cigars in Toledo, chances are you already know Percy. He owns Cigar Merchant, and by all accounts he's the reason people keep coming back. Walk in browsing the humidor and there's a good chance he'll come over and ask what you like to smoke, then point you toward something you hadn't tried. One fellow told the story of naming off a few favorites and walking out with a recommendation called Nick that he couldn't stop thanking Percy for.

The selection is what you'd hope for from a small locally owned brick-and-mortar and then some. Regulars talk about grabbing names like Padrón 1926 and My Father, and the word around Toledo is that the prices stay reasonable, which isn't always a given at a shop this size. Alongside the cigars you'll find the smoking accessories to go with them. The vibe here is easy-going and laid-back, the kind of place where you can sit down and let the day roll off.

More than one seasoned smoker has said Percy is a genuinely good host, personable and knowledgeable, the sort of owner who turns a quick stop into a long conversation. One lifelong cigar smoker mentioned it was his first time ever smoking in a shop, and Percy made him feel right at home. Ask anyone who shops here and you'll hear the same thing: friendly owner, solid selection, a warm welcome whether it's your first visit or your fiftieth. That reputation shows, and it's earned Cigar Merchant a strong following among Toledo cigar folks.

If you spot the sign, do yourself a favor and stop in.