The Tobacco Company

If you're looking for a real cigar shop in Lemoyne, The Tobacco Company is the kind of place that earns its reputation fast. Locals will tell you the humidor here is something to behold, kept well and stocked deep, with product running from the floor practically to the ceiling. It can feel a little overwhelming the first time you walk in, but that's the fun of it. The selection covers every level of smoker, from the person picking up a special-occasion stick for their dad to the seasoned enthusiast hunting something exotic. The brand list reads like a who's who of the cigar world.

Padron, Arturo Fuente, Ashton, Davidoff, Liga Privada, Rocky Patel, My Father lines like Don Pepin and La Aroma de Cuba, plus Drew Estate favorites that people around here rave about. Cohiba, Montecristo, Romeo y Julieta, Oliva, Perdomo, Camacho, Tatuaje, the whole spread. They also carry cigarettes, tobacco pipes, and the accessories to go with them. One regular swears by the Maduro house cigar for its even burn and taste, and folks appreciate that the sticks come properly humidified rather than over-humidified. The lounge is where this place really wins people over.

Cozy, clean, and a little classy, with several televisions usually tuned to whatever game is on. You can bring your own food and drink or grab a soda or water there, then settle in with something you bought that day. Ask anyone who shops here and they'll mention the gentleman behind the counter, welcoming to strangers and genuinely helpful when you need a recommendation. More than one out-of-towner passing through on business has decided to make it a regular stop. Prices are fair and honest, nothing wildly marked up.

There's an old-school touch where you note the price of your cigars yourself, but they give fair warning and nobody seems to mind. One of the highest-regarded smoke shops in the Lemoyne area, and it's easy to see why.