Total Tobacco #401

Total Tobacco #401 has been a fixture for cigar lovers in Newtown Square since 1999, and more than two decades in, it remains one of the better-regarded tobacco shops around. The word around town is that this is a real cigar shop, with a large, well-kept humidor and a selection deep enough that regulars have ditched most of their mail-order buying to pick up their sticks here instead. One local found his Perdomo vintage aged 12 years in bourbon and called it a great cigar, and people who shop here swear by the fresh, consistent quality of the smokes. The humidor reads like a serious lineup: Padron, Oliva, Ashton, Arturo Fuente, Rocky Patel, Macanudo, Davidoff and Perdomo alongside boutique names like Emilio, Black Label Trading Company, Dissident and Drew Estate.

Beyond cigars, they carry tobacco pipes, cigarettes, and the accessories and smoking gear to round it all out. Rolling your own? They stock tubes and papers and will point you toward what works. If you're after General Snus, ask anyone who shops here: they keep it cold.

The team is a big part of why folks keep coming back. Sal, Sean, Harry and Fab get named again and again by longtime regulars, some of whom have shopped here since the doors opened. Friendly, knowledgeable, and quick to make a recommendation, they know their inventory and usually have exactly what you came in for on hand. Now and then someone runs into a hiccup at the counter or over a return, but that's the exception, and the overall feeling toward this shop stays warm.

Hours are steady and easy to plan around: open seven days a week, Monday through Saturday 9 to 7 and Sunday 10 to 5. For anyone hunting a genuine cigar shop and tobacco store in Newtown Square, Pennsylvania, this one earns its loyal following.