Cigarro

Cigarro has quickly become one of the most talked-about cigar shops in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, and the word around town is that it earns every bit of that reputation. Ask anyone who has spent an afternoon here and they'll point to John and Amanda first. The husband-and-wife team, along with Chuck, run the place with the kind of warmth you don't always find in a brick-and-mortar shop, and locals will tell you that's exactly what keeps them coming back. The selection is a big part of the draw.

This is a spot that carries boutique names people actually seek out, from Tatuaje to Herrera Estelí to Alec Bradley's The Lineage, with humidor closets tucked throughout so there's plenty to explore. If you're new to it all, John takes the time to explain the differences and steer you toward something you'll enjoy. One fellow who set up a cigar bar for his wedding had John help him pick boxes for the reception and individual smokes for his groomsmen, and the whole thing was a hit. Regulars swear by the owner's recommendations too, saying every cigar he's told them to try has been right on the mark.

The lounge itself gets just as much love. People describe it as clean, bright, and well-ventilated, with multiple seating areas, nice TVs for the game, and easy parking right out front. BYOB is a welcome bonus, and folks keep an eye on Instagram and Facebook for the events they host. It's the kind of place where you can settle in and talk shop with people who genuinely know their stuff.

There's a customer-first spirit here that stands on its own. One person brought in a torch lighter he hadn't even bought at Cigarro, and Chuck tinkered with it until he got it sorted. A traveler from Canada called it a lesser-known option and left raving about the hospitality. For a cigar shop in Pittsburgh, that's saying something.